Book Review: The Heist Before Christmas, Lucy Score

‘Tis the season for mayhem, mistletoe, and one very unfortunate mall uniform.

Engaged. Overwhelmed. Running a small business with a purple-haired octogenarian who thinks “Rhonda El Bano” is a convincing alias. For reluctant psychic Riley Thorn, the holidays are less “magic in the air” and more “fire in the living room.” Between the backlog of invoices, a PI license teetering on revocation, a disapproving grandmother lobbing ominous predictions about the upcoming wedding, and the fact that Riley cannot see a single thing about her own future with Nick Santiago, she just wants to survive until December 26th.

Nick Santiago doesn’t do “mellow.” He does Christmas. Hard. He’s the man who owns a twelve-foot inflatable Santa and feels no shame about it. So if closing out the year means going undercover at the East Shore Mall to catch a slippery theft ring―even if it costs him one truly terrible security uniform and several shifts with the world’s most punchable assistant manager―fine. The sooner he catches the bad guy, the sooner he can haul his fiancée under the mistletoe and convince her everything is going to be fine.

Between mall chaos, psychic guild parties, warring families descending for Christmas Eve dinner, and one stray kitten who has personally destroyed two rooms and a dog’s dignity, they have five days to catch a thief, save a license―

And figure out why the future looks so suspiciously blank.

Shop The Book: The Heist Before Christmas
Shop The Author: Lucy Score
Shop My Stack: 2026 Books Read

This was my first time reading a Lucy Score book. I see her all over Bookstagram and Goodreads, but I’d always pegged her as a romance author, and lately I’ve been deep in thrillers and gothic paranormal. The holidays always make me lean a little more toward romance and sap, though, so I grabbed this one, and now I’m honestly wondering why I waited so long. Because this isn’t sappy romance at all. It’s quirky, witty, and so funny. I was laughing out loud, snorting, underlining, and reading quotes to my husband the entire way through.

If you were psychic but couldn’t see a single thing about your own future, would you want to find out what was coming, or would you rather be surprised?

The Story

Reluctant psychic Riley Thorn is engaged, overwhelmed, and just trying to survive until December 26th. Between a backlog of invoices, a PI license teetering on revocation, a business partner with purple hair and questionable alias skills, and a grandmother lobbing ominous predictions about the wedding, the holidays feel less like magic and more like a fire in the living room. Worst of all, Riley can’t see a single thing about her own future with Nick Santiago. Nick, meanwhile, does Christmas hard, and he’s going undercover at the East Shore Mall in a truly terrible security uniform to catch a slippery theft ring. With mall chaos, psychic guild parties, warring families descending for Christmas Eve dinner, and one destructive stray kitten, they have five days to catch a thief, save a license, and figure out why the future looks so suspiciously blank.

Reading Experience

This is book five in the Riley Thorn series, and it absolutely holds its own as a standalone. Still, it made me want to go back and start from the beginning, because the characters alone are enough to make me curious about the earlier books.

Writing Style

At its core, this is an investigative mystery, but what I loved most is how people-focused it is. We don’t just peek inside the undercover work. We get inside the characters’ heads too: how they interact, what they’re thinking and feeling, how they lean on each other, and how they drive each other crazy. It’s such a personal, personable story. The characters and their relationships come first, and the mystery comes second, which for me is always a win.

Characters

Riley and Nick are an absolute riot together. They say the most ridiculous things to each other in this bold, blunt, comedic way, and I loved every second. Sarcasm and snark are my love language in a book, and these two cover all the bases. I loved them together, but they also hold their own separately, in their scenes with other characters and in their own storylines. I was so emotionally invested in how Nick’s undercover investigation would go, in everything Riley was dealing with around her intuition, and in how it would all bring them back together.

And oh my gosh, the side characters! Nick’s band of undercover misfits helping with his investigation are an absolute hoot. They reminded me so much of the colorful, quirky side characters in Gilmore Girls: weird, silly, a little “is everything okay in there?”, and impossible not to love. Riley has her own cloud of quirky characters following her story too, and even though they all share that offbeat energy, each one is written so uniquely that their personalities never blur together.

Then there are the older roommates, who are pure comedy. I want to go back and read the earlier books just to figure out why in the world all these people share a house together.

Heartbeat

The heartbeat of this one doesn’t fully come together until the very end, so I won’t say too much. Throughout the story, Riley struggles with her identity as a psychic and her abilities. She keeps doubting herself, questioning whether she’s any good, and wondering if she can really help people when they need it. Her journey is all about learning to trust herself, her intuition, and her inner strength, and realizing that she is enough.

Final Thoughts

I feel a little silly for never picking up a Lucy Score book before, because I automatically lumped her in with sappy romance, and she’s not that at all. Her writing has such an edgy, quirky, funny vibe, and I’m definitely looking forward to reading more of her books.

I received a complimentary copy of this book from Hambright PR.
All thoughts and opinions are my own.

Lucy Score is an instant #1 New York Times bestselling author of contemporary romance including Things We Never Got Over. She has sold more than 15 million books worldwide. Before earning a degree in journalism, she grew up in a literary family who insisted that the dinner table was for reading.

Her books have been translated into more than thirty-five languages around the world. Her international bestselling Knockemout series has been optioned for television.

She writes full-time from the Pennsylvania home she shares with Mr. Lucy and an army of houseplants. When not writing romance so steamy her family can’t look her in the eye, Lucy can be found reading books other people wrote and snacking.

Catch up with Lucy on Instagram @scorelucy or her website lucyscore dot com

Leave a Reply

I’m Ashley

Welcome to my Blog! Here, you’ll find my honest reviews of books that touched my soul, books that were great for a weekend in, or maybe some books that weren’t my cup of tea. I’ll also share my favorite products and how they help make our home cozy and efficient. I love to connect so make yourselves friendly in the comments!

Follow me on YouTube!

Follow me on Insta!